Long before the modern civil rights movement galvanized the nation in the 1950s and 1960s, a remarkable white Southern woman named Lillian Smith was already on the front lines, fighting fiercely to dismantle the entrenched systems of segregation in the American South. Writing best-selling books that challenged the established racial hierarchy, Smith faced intense backlash, including having her works censored, banned, and publicly burned across various cities in the United States. Yet, despite her profound contributions to American literature and social justice, her name has largely faded from contemporary public memory. In an effort to correct this historical oversight, historian and author Keri Leigh Merritt is working to bring Smith’s extraordinary legacy back into the light, shedding new light on a figure whose life and ideas deserve widespread recognition.

The connection between Merritt and Smith began on a crisp early autumn day during Merritt’s first visit to Old Screamer Mountain, the secluded home where Smith lived and worked for sixty-eight years. Located in Clayton, Georgia, the site overlooks the breathtaking vistas of the Appalachians. As Merritt observed the vibrant foliage—a brilliant display of oranges, reds, golds, maroons, mustards, and burnt siennas signaling the brief transition of the seasons—the familiar, serene landscape immediately felt like home.

In the months of research that followed, Merritt discovered striking parallels between her own life and that of the pioneering writer. Both born in the Deep South—Smith in Florida and Merritt in Mississippi—each ultimately chose Georgia as her home, despite finding herself in sharp ideological disagreement with the majority of the state’s white citizenry. Both women navigated childhoods burdened by complicated, troubling relationships with their mothers and found their worldviews profoundly shaped by extensive travel, particularly abroad, during their youth. Furthermore, both experienced significant interruptions in their life’s work due to serious illness and had to overcome major personal losses.

Their philosophical approaches to social change mirrored each other as well. Both Smith and Merritt shared the conviction that dismantling systemic racism required a multifaceted strategy combining personal relationships, education, art, psychology, and public policy. They launched their public speaking careers through similar avenues, addressing audiences at civil rights organizations, Southern colleges, and private institutions in New York. Both women possessed an impatience and a moral rigor—perhaps bordering on self-righteousness at times—along with an admitted intolerance for bigotry. Above all, both stood far more progressive than the majority of white Americans of their respective generations.

Intrigued by the diminutive, wire-framed intellectual of Old Screamer Mountain, Merritt immersed herself in comprehensive research. She uncovered a complex figure: a white woman who actively fought against segregation as early as the 1930s, a commercially successful author whose books faced censorship, burning, and bans across multiple American cities, and an openly lesbian woman who shared her life and work with her lifelong partner, Paula Snelling. Merritt concluded that Smith had been nearly erased from the historical narrative because her very existence and ideology posed—and continue to pose—a direct challenge to prevailing hierarchies and power structures.

Remembering Lillian Smith

Smith’s contributions, Merritt argues, demand a prominent place in American education. Her essays should be standard reading in classrooms, and entire college courses should be dedicated to exploring her written works and activism. As Merritt’s research expanded into a full-length book project titled An Inconvenient Woman, she began collaborating closely with Matthew Teutsch, who served as the Director of the Lillian Smith Center prior to its defunding by Piedmont University. Teutsch dedicated years of tireless effort to restoring Smith’s legacy, culminating on April 20, 2022, when the Georgia Historical Society finally dedicated an official historical marker in her honor.

The marker acknowledges Smith’s pivotal role in the region, noting that she openly challenged Jim Crow and provided a critical white voice on Southern race relations through her writings, including her famous novel Strange Fruit, her seminal memoir Killers of the Dream, and a literary magazine co-edited with her life partner, Paula Snelling. The text also highlights her active involvement with civil rights organizations, which led to a friendship with Martin Luther King Jr.

By explicitly recognizing Paula Snelling as Lillian’s life and intellectual partner, the marker achieved a historic milestone, becoming one of—if not the—first historical markers in the Deep South to acknowledge a same-sex relationship. It also stands as one of the exceedingly rare markers in the entire state of Georgia dedicated to honoring a woman. In a Southern landscape densely populated with Civil War monuments, the revolutionary nature of Smith’s plaque is profound. Among thousands of markers honoring men, and standing as one of the few recognizing an LGBTQ+ individual, Smith remains a singular white Southerner officially commemorated for an unwavering dedication to civil rights.

By the time the plaque was approved, Merritt had delivered numerous speeches on Smith’s historical importance, establishing herself as a leading expert on the author. When Dr. Teutsch invited Merritt to deliver the keynote address at the marker’s dedication ceremony, she realized she needed to prioritize completing An Inconvenient Woman, marking the first book in forty years to fully examine Smith’s life, work, and sexuality.

In her dedication speech, Merritt focused on how Lillian Smith unflinchingly exposed the moral failings and sins of white America while simultaneously maintaining an unyielding sense of hope that could light a path forward. Smith was known to scold and preach, yet she consistently welcomed metaphorical sinners back with open arms and a forgiving heart. She maintained that the key to achieving genuine peace lay in constructing new identities for white supremacists whose self-images had been destabilized by modernization and progress. As Smith famously wrote, when individuals are asked to surrender old defenses and beliefs, they will not feel secure unless something equal or better is offered in return, emphasizing the necessity of providing people with new beliefs and new self-images to replace the old ones.

These principles—forging new beliefs and new images of society—serve as enduring recipes for social healing, even in the modern era. As Merritt emphasized during the historical marker dedication, keeping Lillian Smith’s name and her vital mission alive is essential for guiding and inspiring future generations. Her life stands as a powerful reminder of the demanding, often selfless, and sometimes perilous labor required to build an equitable, peaceful, and loving society, urging contemporary citizens to take up the mantle in honor of Smith and all fearless freedom fighters who came before them.