When historians and paper money enthusiasts delve into the intricate mechanics of 19th-century American currency production, they generally expect a high degree of precision. After all, the Bureau of Engraving and Printing operated under rigorous protocols designed to catch mistakes before currency ever reached the American public. Yet, numismatic history occasionally reveals anomalies that slip through the institutional cracks.

A remarkable historical discovery has brought to light a fascinating tale of two distinct face plates manufactured decades apart for a single institution: The Annville National Bank of Pennsylvania, operating under charter 2384. Both plates contained notable design errors, a statistical anomaly that leaves modern researchers shaking their heads. The first error occurred on a Series of 1875 10-10-10-20 face plate crafted in 1878 when the bank was initially chartered. The second occurred on a Series of 1882 5-5-5-5 face plate produced twenty years later, in 1898, when the corporate life of the bank was officially extended.

The burning question that has captivated researchers is whether notes bearing these distinct errors ever managed to escape the printing presses and reach everyday circulation.

The discovery of these twin errors is credited to Adam Stroup, a primary contributor to the Society of Paper Money Collectors Bank and Bankers Database, widely recognized as a premier resource for numismatic research. Stroup stumbled onto the problems after reviewing an article detailing the origins of the plate certification process instituted by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing in 1878. That specific verification workflow was established to check the absolute accuracy of plates before they were officially sent to press. As historical fate would have it, the 10-10-10-20 Annville plate was the second such plate ever to undergo this formal certification process.

Living in the vicinity of Annville, Pennsylvania, Stroup felt a natural local and historical compulsion to pull up the archival proofs for the bank to examine their visual details. With an eagle eye for minute design discrepancies, he spotted the incorrect plate letter on the 1875 $20 denomination. Furthermore, his archival deep dive uncovered two distinct proofs for the 1882 5-5-5-5 plate bearing two separate Treasury signature combinations. It was a textbook case of historical serendipity.

To understand how these errors manifested, it is necessary to examine the foundational history of the institution itself. The Annville National Bank was formally organized on April 17, 1878, and officially chartered a month later with an initial capitalization of $50,000. Under the banking regulations of the era, this capitalization permitted the institution to maintain a maximum note circulation of $45,000. Seeking to establish their circulating currency, the bank’s leadership elected to take out their allowance in the form of 5-5-5-5 and 10-10-10-20 sheets.

The bankers placed an initial order with the Comptroller of the Currency for 600 sheets of the 10-10-10-20 denomination mix, which translated to $30,000 worth of national currency. That order, coupled with an auxiliary order for $5 sheets, successfully covered their initial shipment needs while providing the Comptroller’s office with approximately a one- to two-year supply of replacement notes to redeem worn currency returned from circulation.

The 10-10-10-20 face plate for the bank was officially certified on May 27, 1878, by Bureau Chief Edward McPherson. However, what completely slipped past the watchful eyes of the inspectors and McPherson was a significant blunder involving the plate letters. The siderographer accidentally rolled in the letter D instead of the letter A in the upper right corner of the $20 note position. Curiously, he got the letter A right in the lower left corner. Under the standard layout conventions of the period, each denomination on a multi-note plate maintained its own internal lettering sequence. Therefore, on the 10-10-10-20 plate, the proper corner letters for the notes should have followed an A-B-C-A sequence.

The printed sheets were promptly delivered to the Comptroller’s office on June 21, 1878, carrying sheet serial numbers 1 through 600 and plate serial numbers B839553 through B840152. The entire batch was dispatched directly to the bank on that same day, followed shortly by 750 sheets of 5-5-5-5 denominations on June 24, which fulfilled the total circulation allotment due to the bank.

Given the timeline of the production and distribution, the inescapable conclusion is that the error-laden $20 notes undoubtedly entered active circulation.

Eventually, someone—most likely an observant official within the Bureau of Engraving and Printing—spotted the mistake. The proof was pulled from active archives, and a skilled siderographer was assigned to repair the plate. During the repair process, the craftsman left a permanent historical footnote written directly into the bottom margin of the proof: "Check letter D should have been letter A on the $20. Repaired Oct 2d 1878—This plate was made during my shift Oct 2d 1878."

The subsequent printing from the corrected plate took place on December 1, 1879, during which 100 sheets bearing serial numbers 601 through 700 and plate serials D426598 through D426697 were produced. The first ten sheets from that second printing run were dispatched to the bank on May 7, 1880.

Two decades later, the corporate life of the bank reached its statutory limit and was extended for a second 20-year term in 1898. This administrative milestone required the creation of an entirely new series of 1882 plates. The official date of the bank’s extension, April 18, 1898, was deliberately utilized as the plate date on the newly engraved plates. Under the prevailing convention of the era, the Treasury signatures printed on the notes were required to reflect those currently in office on the official plate date.

The $5 Series of 1882 plate was manufactured in advance and consequently certified on March 2, 1898, during the tenure of the Bruce-Roberts administration. As a result, those specific signatures were rolled directly into the plate by the siderographer. However, a bureaucratic complication arose when the Lyons-Roberts signature combination officially became current on April 7, 1898. Because the plate date was April 18, the newer Lyons-Roberts combination should have been mated to the plate instead.

This discrepancy was caught in the nick of time before widespread damage occurred. The plate was modified by mechanically replacing the Bruce signature with that of Lyons. The revised plate was then re-certified on April 22 and sent straight to the press to produce 1,250 sheets. However, these sheets were not finalized in time to meet their originally scheduled delivery date of March 22 under their pre-assigned sheet serial numbers of 1 through 1250 and plate serials Z989186 through Z990310. Instead, the completed sheets were delivered to the Comptroller’s office on May 4, with sheets 1 through 41 shipped directly to the bank that same day.

In this second instance, historical records confirm that Stroup had not discovered an issued error circulating among the public, as the plate was successfully corrected prior to general distribution.

An interesting footnote to the bank’s printing history involves the composition of its note denominations. The bankers initially planned to utilize exclusively $5 denominations for their entire Series of 1882 note issues. However, the sweeping legislative changes introduced by the Gold Standard Act, passed on March 14, 1900, mandated that no more than one-third of a national bank’s total note circulation could be issued in the form of $5 denominations. Complying with the new federal law, the bank was forced to order a 10-10-10-20 plate. That plate was officially certified on July 14, 1900, carried the retrospective April 18, 1898 date of extension, and properly featured the correct Lyons-Roberts signature combination.

Reflecting on the totality of these archival findings, researchers find a striking irony in the fact that two distinct plates manufactured for the exact same financial institution, separated across a timeline of twenty years, both contained notable errors. While isolated engraving errors were exceedingly rare occurrences within the highly regulated environment of the Bureau of Engraving and Printing, a single bank drawing a double header of distinct production blunders remains virtually unprecedented in the annals of national bank note collecting.

For the historical figures managing The Annville National Bank, it seemed simply to be a matter of unfortunate timing and indifferent bureaucratic luck.