More than two decades after Jon Favreau’s “Elf” enchanted holiday audiences and cemented itself as a modern Christmas classic, revelations continue to emerge about the strange, unproduced paths the franchise almost took. Among the most bizarre pieces of Hollywood trivia to surface is the disclosure that David Howell Evans—better known as The Edge, the iconic lead guitarist of the legendary rock band U2—once took it upon himself to write a full-length screenplay for a sequel to the Will Ferrell-starrer.

The surprising behind-the-scenes anecdote was recently shared by actor and comedian Andy Richter during an appearance on an episode of “Obsessed: The Podcast.” Richter, who played a brief role as one of Walter Hobbs’ publishing colleagues in the 2003 original and has recently authored the new behind-the-scenes book “Elf Unwrapped: Behind the Scenes of a Modern Christmas Classic,” offered listeners a rare glimpse into the hidden history of the holiday favorite.

According to Richter, the bizarre pitch first crossed paths with Shauna Robertson, who served as a producer on the original film. Someone from The Edge’s camp reached out to Robertson with an unexpected proposition, delivering the news that the rock musician had penned a complete script for “Elf 2” and was eager to discuss bringing it to the screen.

“Somebody reached out to her and said, ‘The Edge from U2 has written a sequel to “Elf,” and he wants to talk to you about it,’” Richter recounted during the podcast episode. “It’s the weirdest story, but apparently it was fully written. Somewhere in the world there is an Edge-penned ‘Elf 2’ out there… I would love for that to make the light of day. It never happened. It’s one of those things where she’s like, ‘All right, sure, I’ll meet him,’ and then it just petered out and never happened.”

While the notion of a U2-penned holiday comedy sequel sounds like a premise ripped straight from a fictional satire, it was not the only attempt made to continue the adventures of Buddy the Elf. Richter revealed that The Edge was not the only writer to take a crack at a follow-up. Scot Armstrong, a seasoned comedy writer known for his work on “Old School” and “The Hangover Part II,” also drafted a separate sequel script. Richter noted that Armstrong had actually contributed to the writing process of the original “Elf,” though he ultimately went uncredited due to guild rules and procedural technicalities within the Writers Guild of America.

Armstrong’s version of the sequel would have taken the holiday narrative in a much more antagonistic direction. According to Richter, that particular script focused on “the evil South Pole elves kidnapping Santa or something like that.”

Despite these various attempts to capitalize on the massive commercial and cultural footprint of the original film, a sequel never materialized. Now, more than twenty years after the movie first hit theaters, Richter remains steadfast in his conviction that a follow-up was—and still is—entirely unnecessary. Reflecting on the enduring legacy of the holiday favorite, the actor and author argued that leaving the film untouched is the best possible outcome for its legacy.

“I’m on the side of ‘Let it stand,’” Richter said during the podcast. “Just let ‘Elf’ be ‘Elf.’ You don’t have to use every part of the animal.”

He elaborated on why tampering with the beloved property would be a risky endeavor, pointing out that time has only enhanced the movie’s reputation and protective status among fans.

“Now that time has passed, the movie has become so special that I think that people, rightfully so, are loath to mess with it because we all can think of movies that have been tarnished by their sequels,” Richter continued. “And this is so special and so perfect and so beloved… Why risk it?”

Directed by Jon Favreau and released in November 2003, “Elf” quickly grew from a well-received holiday release into a perennial seasonal staple. The film starred Will Ferrell as Buddy, a human raised by elves at the North Pole who discovers his true heritage and travels to New York City to find his biological father, a cynical book publisher named Walter Hobbs, played by the late James Caan. Alongside Ferrell and Caan, the movie featured a stellar cast including Zooey Deschanel, Mary Steenburgen, Edward Asner, and Bob Newhart.

The film’s unique blend of physical comedy, sincere holiday sentiment, and memorable performances has kept it firmly entrenched in popular culture for over two decades. Its staying power is precisely why fans continue to debate the merits of potential continuations while simultaneously expressing relief that the original movie was never subjected to a diluted franchise expansion.

For Richter, looking back at the production of the film and compiling his new book has offered a fresh appreciation for the lightning-in-a-bottle nature of the original project. Whether the mysterious script written by U2’s guitarist will ever see the light of day remains to be seen, but for now, audiences seem content to keep celebrating the original North Pole-to-Manhattan journey just the way it is.