For many homeowners, the challenge of a layout that refuses to "work" is a source of constant frustration. For Montana Labelle, a professional interior designer and founder of Montana Labelle Design, it became an opportunity for an architectural and stylistic experiment. Labelle and her husband, Brendan Tadler, found themselves baffled by a second-floor living room in their Long Island, New York, home. Despite its impressive features—including a grand fireplace and soaring ten-and-a-half-foot ceilings—the space remained chronically underutilized. It was, by all logical measures, superior to the sitting room on the ground floor, yet it remained a social desert. “We were like, ‘What is wrong with this room?’ It can seat 30 people, but no one ever hangs out here,” Labelle admits. Over the course of several months, the couple attempted to solve the puzzle through a series of failed iterations. Initially dressed in crisp, white slipcovered furniture and accented by a delicate silk rug, the room felt sterile and uninviting. They pivoted, transforming the space into a home office, but it failed to capture their interest. They then tried repurposing it as a dedicated playroom for their young daughter, a move that proved equally unsuccessful. After six distinct attempts at finding the right configuration, the solution arrived unexpectedly while Labelle was shopping for furniture in Toronto with a client. She realized the room required a radical departure from conventional layouts: a monolithic, 20-foot-long, wall-to-wall sofa, and a total color-drenching in a deep, moody shade of burgundy. The transformation was immediate and effective. “Now it’s the room we hang out in all the time!” she says. Read Also: The Evolution of the Advent Calendar: From Childhood Tradition to Sophisticated Seasonal Ritual The Modern Countdown: Why Advent Calendars Have Become the Ultimate Holiday Essential This bold aesthetic choice serves as a microcosm for the couple’s broader approach to their home in Wading River. Situated on Long Island’s North Shore, the property stands in stark contrast to the region’s ubiquitous coastal Hamptons aesthetic. Rather than opting for the bright, airy palettes synonymous with the area, Labelle and Tadler have embraced a darker, more textural, and deeply personal design language. The renovation, which has spanned the last two years, has been a comprehensive overhaul of both the interior and the surrounding landscape. The couple views the residence not merely as a family home, but as a living laboratory. “We treat our home as an experiment for future projects,” Labelle notes. This experimental spirit is evident in the material choices throughout the house, most notably the widespread use of mineral-based limewash from Color Atelier. The application of this finish provides a depth and soul to the walls that standard paint cannot replicate. The history of the property itself necessitated a significant vision. When the couple first toured the home, it had been sitting on the market for an entire year. Labelle recalls the initial state of the exterior with a mixture of amusement and horror. “It was probably the ugliest exterior I’ve ever seen: the shutters were painted black and red with psychedelic swirls. It was pretty scary. The landscaping was awful. But we saw a lot of potential.” That potential was unlocked through a series of tactical interventions. Tadler spearheaded the outdoor improvements, starting with an expansion of the driveway to accommodate the steady stream of guests they host on weekends. The landscaping efforts were equally ambitious, involving the planting of over 400 specimens, including a sprawling lavender garden containing roughly one hundred plants. By prioritizing drought-resistant and native species, they have created an environment that feels both lush and low-maintenance—a balance that aligns with their desired lifestyle. Inside, the floor plan underwent significant revisions as the couple lived in the space during the renovation. Their original plan called for an open-concept kitchen paired with a formal dining room. However, daily life revealed that a formal dining area was an unnecessary luxury for their family. They decided to reallocate that square footage, converting the intended dining room into a cozy, intimate television and sitting area. This shift was part of a larger strategy to unify the ground floor, which had previously been paneled in dark, oppressive wood. By lightening the palette and optimizing the flow, they ensured that the kitchen, the heart of the home, now allows for a seamless connection to the family room, enabling parents to prepare meals while keeping a watchful eye on their daughter. The home is filled with eclectic treasures that reflect the synthesis of Labelle’s design sensibilities and Tadler’s appreciation for the classics. A prime example is the inclusion of a monumental bust by Belgian artist Florian Tomballe, which serves as a striking focal point in the galley kitchen. The kitchen itself hides a surprise: the backsplash is not tile, but a custom-painted mural. The burgundy living room, which finally brought peace to their second-floor conundrum, centers on a marble fireplace mantel that serves as the room’s anchor. Found at a local antique shop called Lumber and Salt just ten minutes from their home, the piece was acquired for a mere $100. It served as the catalyst for the entire room’s color palette. The resulting space is a testament to comfort; the custom sofa, measuring six-and-a-half feet deep, functions as a family gathering spot for movies and, occasionally, a jungle gym for their toddler. The couple’s commitment to customization extends to the practicalities of raising a child in a high-design environment. Rather than relying on standard plastic baby gates that often disrupt the visual flow of an interior, they commissioned a custom, perforated Dutch door. It serves its protective purpose without sacrificing the architectural integrity of the home. In the primary suite, the design team faced the challenge of an off-center window. Rather than engaging in expensive structural reconstruction, they opted for a creative solution: a massive tapestry salvaged from Labelle’s previous residence, which was then motorized to function as a Roman shade. The headboard is a simple, effective piece of DIY craftsmanship, constructed by Tadler using 2x4s and finished with plaster. Perhaps the most unconventional addition to the private quarters is the inclusion of a bathtub directly in the bedroom. During their travels, the couple frequently stayed in hotels that utilized this layout, and they were struck by the intimacy and functionality it offered. “Typically I’m in the bath and I’ll talk to my husband while he’s lying in bed,” Labelle explains. Burcu Garnier, co-founder of Color Atelier, notes that the couple’s use of their waterproof plaster treatment, specifically in the shade "Wabi," challenges traditional perceptions of the material. While often associated with rustic, heavily textured environments, the treatment demonstrates a refined, contemporary sensibility when applied in lighter tones. This commitment to texture is echoed in the lighting throughout the house, much of which is custom-sourced from Labelle’s own lifestyle shop. By finishing the light fixtures in the same paint or limewash as the walls, they have achieved a seamless, integrated look that emphasizes form over decoration. The home continues to evolve. Even the outdoor spaces, designed for social gatherings, have their own learning curves. Tadler notes that their outdoor pizza oven, while a source of entertainment, has proven to be a difficult skill to master. “It is a really fun thing when we’re entertaining to say, ‘Hey, do you want to make some pizzas?’ It usually turns into a disaster. Turns out, it’s very difficult!” Through every room—from the nursery where a canopy was replaced by a tapestry when the architecture wouldn’t accommodate the original plan, to the bathrooms where limewash has replaced more costly Venetian plaster—Labelle and Tadler have demonstrated a willingness to pivot and iterate. Their home serves as a narrative of design as a process, where mistakes, budget-friendly hacks, and bold risks coalesce into a space that is profoundly, uniquely their own. Post navigation Spoonflower Launches Major November Sale: Significant Discounts on Wallpaper and Textiles The Beauty Editor’s Dilemma: How to Master Product Organization in a Saturated Space