For half a century, Robert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr. have stood as titans in the field of Buddhist studies. As the Distinguished Research Professor of Buddhist Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles, and the Arthur E. Link Distinguished University Professor of Buddhist and Tibetan Studies at the University of Michigan, respectively, they have shaped the academic landscape of the tradition for generations. Yet, despite their immense contributions to scholarship, the two longtime friends have rarely offered a window into their own personal journeys or the informal dialogues that define their intellectual partnership.

That changes with their new book, Talking About Buddhism: Two Lifetimes of Learning, Teaching, and (Some) Practice. Structured as a series of wide-ranging conversations, the volume bridges the gap between high-level academic rigor and the lived reality of two scholars who have spent their lives analyzing the doctrine and practice of Tibetan and East Asian traditions. Among the many questions the pair tackles—ranging from the mechanics of enlightenment to the tension between theory and experience—is perhaps the most perennial and misunderstood query in the field: What, or where, is nirvana?

The Question That Never Fails

For Buswell, the topic is unavoidable. "The time has finally come, Don, to tackle the one question we always seem to get asked at just about every public talk, even scholarly presentations," he notes in the book. It is not the cheeky, inevitable inquiry of "Are you enlightened?"—a question the scholars wisely dodge—but the persistent, fundamental demand to define nirvana.

Buswell recalls a keynote address he delivered at a conference on Korean philosophy where, despite meticulously avoiding the word "nirvana" throughout his entire presentation, the very first audience question was, inevitably, "What is nirvana?" This reflects the pervasive, if vague, status of the term in the modern Western imagination. In contemporary culture, the word has been stripped of its theological weight, commodified by brands ranging from CBD oils and spring waters to fashion labels. For advertisers, "nirvana" serves as a convenient shorthand for a state of bliss or escape from the mundane, a trend that underscores a collective, if superficial, desire for something beyond the humdrum of daily life.

What Is Nirvana?

However, within the Buddhist tradition, the concept is far more complex and elusive. Buswell points to the Udana, a foundational text, where the Buddha describes a dimension (ayatana) devoid of the elements of earth, water, fire, and wind—a place beyond space, perception, and the cycles of coming and going. It is, by definition, the end of suffering. Yet, as Buswell observes, this is "apophatic theology," or a description via negativa: the Buddha tells us what nirvana is not, rather than what it is.

The Baseball Analogy: Understanding the Rules of the Game

To make sense of such an abstract concept, Buswell employs a pedagogical tool he adapted from the scholar Ninian Smart: a baseball analogy. If one were to explain a home run to someone entirely unfamiliar with the sport, one would first need to explain the entire game—the teams, the innings, the base paths, and the objective of scoring. Only once the rules of the game are understood can the significance of a home run emerge.

Nirvana, Buswell argues, is the "Buddhist home run." To grasp its meaning, one must first engage with the "rules" of Buddhism: the three marks of existence (impermanence, suffering, and no-self), the necessity of the "three trainings" (morality, concentration, and wisdom), and the gradual development of radical nonattachment. The goal of this training is to cultivate a deep-seated disillusionment with the ephemeral nature of the world—what Buddhists call nirvedha.

This process leads the practitioner through the "three gates to deliverance": emptiness, signlessness, and wishlessness. One must realize that nirvana is not an object to be attained, nor a place to be inhabited by a self. Indeed, as long as one desires nirvana, it remains out of reach, as the desire itself acts as a form of clinging. The paradox, as Buswell articulates, is that one must eventually let go of the very teachings and methods that led them to the threshold. He cites the Buddha’s famous simile of the raft: once one has crossed the raging river of birth and death, one does not carry the raft on one’s back. "To truly understand Buddhism, we must let go of our attachment even to Buddhism itself," Buswell writes.

What Is Nirvana?

The Paradox of Experience

When the practitioner finally passes through these gates, the experience of nirvana occurs. Yet, this is not an experience in the conventional sense, as there is no "person" left to experience it. It is a flash of insight on the "path of vision," where the fundamental, lifelong error of perceiving a "self" at the center of the world is permanently shattered.

The question of "where" nirvana is, however, remains a category error. Buswell compares it to a candle flame being extinguished. It does not travel to a new location; it simply ceases to be. When the Buddha was asked by his followers whether a liberated sage continues to exist after death or vanishes into nothingness, he refused to provide a binary answer. He explained that because all "ways of talking" about such a state are rooted in the constructs of the world, they fail to capture the ineffability of the state. One is not so much "achieving" nirvana as being "blown out."

Nirvana in the Eyes of the Tradition

Donald S. Lopez Jr. turns the conversation toward the practical application of the term in Asian Buddhist communities. "Given how difficult it is for the tradition to talk about nirvana," he asks, "it makes you wonder whether the term comes up more often in the American college classroom than it does in common parlance in Asian Buddhist countries."

Buswell confirms that, in his experience, the term is rarely a central topic of discourse among monks or practitioners. In East Asia, it is almost exclusively reserved for the death of an eminent teacher. The focus of daily practice is typically directed toward "enlightenment," "awakening," or "seeing one’s nature," rather than the abstract concept of nirvana. For the layperson, especially in Southeast Asian traditions, nirvana is often viewed as so profoundly inaccessible that religious life is prioritized through merit-making—giving and virtuous acts—aimed at a better rebirth rather than the cessation of existence.

What Is Nirvana?

Visual culture reinforces this. The most prevalent images of the Buddha are not of his final passing, but of his victory over Mara, the earth-touching gesture (bhumisparshamudra) that signifies the moment before his enlightenment. Images of the Buddha in parinirvana—lying in repose at the moment of death—exist, but they are far less central to the devotional life of the tradition.

The Burden of Existence

Lopez, reflecting on the Tibetan perspective, notes that their term for nirvana translates to "passed beyond sorrow." He explains that the Mahayana tradition, particularly through the Lotus Sutra, suggests that the nirvana described in the mainstream schools is not the ultimate end, but rather a step toward the bodhisattva path.

Addressing the skepticism of modern students who might ask, "If nirvana is extinction, why would anyone want that?", Lopez points to the grim reality of the cycle of rebirth. In the Buddhist view, sentient beings have cycled through infinite lives as gods, animals, ghosts, and denizens of hell, and each cycle has invariably ended in suffering. Nirvana is not a surrender to death, but the only true escape from the "inverted views" that keep one trapped in the cycle of pain. It is the definitive response to the existential fatigue of samsara.

As the two scholars conclude their dialogue, they acknowledge the limits of language. Buswell notes that while the Buddha often used the term "the deathless" to describe nirvana, it was never meant to imply eternal life, but rather "eternal imperishability." Since there is no longer a self to be reborn, there is nothing that can die.

What Is Nirvana?

Ultimately, the dialogue between Buswell and Lopez serves as a reminder that the Buddhist path is not about finding a final resting place or a permanent destination. By consistently parrying questions about the nature of the "afterlife" or the location of nirvana, the Buddha may have been attempting to point toward something that, as Wittgenstein once suggested, cannot be spoken of—and perhaps cannot even be whistled.