In their new book, Confronting America, authors Bill O’Reilly and Josh Hammer argue that contemporary Americans have lost sight of the fundamental values that built the nation into a global land of opportunity. According to the authors, no government program can solve this cultural drift. Instead, O’Reilly asserts that "Americans need to wise up" and be willing to place country and community ahead of individual self-interest if the nation is to return to its former standing. Part of Chapter 12 of the bestselling series dives headfirst into how the nation views its highest officeholders, exploring a timeless American tradition: the mythologizing of presidents. While the phenomenon of shaping historical narratives is centuries old, the authors note a modern twist. Today, mainstream media outlets gleefully participate in myth-making, provided a candidate conveniently fits their preferred political ideology. Throughout history, however, major historical inaccuracies and exaggerated folklore have regularly woven their way into the national consciousness, obscuring the genuine human complexities of America’s leaders. Read Also: Unearthing the Legacy of Lillian Smith: The Pioneer Historian Keri Leigh Merritt Wants America to Remember Reframing the Rebellion: A New Look at the Civil War and the Reality of the Confederacy The Real George Washington: Family Strife and Financial Tensions George Washington remains safely enshrined as one of the greatest American heroes of all time. History remembers him as a brilliant military general and the foundational president who tirelessly worked to get the newly formed republic up and running. Yet, the popular mythology surrounding Washington paints an almost impossibly pristine picture. In the public imagination, the man apparently never made a mistake, maintained a perpetually cheerful disposition, and was consistently dashing, perspicacious, and unfailingly kind to every animal he ever encountered. The historical reality, however, reveals a slightly more complicated human being. This is not to diminish Washington’s first-rate heroism, but as O’Reilly outlines in his related work Confronting the Presidents, George’s relationship with his own mother was fraught with tension—and it all centered around money. Mary Ball Washington, a widow, continued to reside on the vast Virginia estate of her deceased husband, Augustine. Eventually, Mary found herself unable to afford the steep costs required to maintain the plantation. Naturally, she turned to her successful son for financial assistance. However, George did not have substantial cash on hand during his military campaigns. Furthermore, his wife, Martha Washington, controlled the family funds while the general was away fighting the British. This financial arrangement did not please Mary Ball. Frustrated by her son’s perceived stinginess, she began writing letters to local Virginia newspapers, openly calling him "cheap" and "mean." Deeply agitated by the public embarrassment, General Washington wrote a candid letter to his mother on February 15, 1787. In the correspondence, he offered direct, pragmatic advice, suggesting she break up her housekeeping, hire out her remaining servants except for a man and a maid, and live with one of her other children to find peace of mind. Mary’s response was direct: she threatened to move in with George and Martha at Mount Vernon. George quickly fired back, explaining that his home was constantly crowded with travelers moving from north to south, functioning much like a busy tavern. He warned her that living there would reduce her to three difficult choices: constantly dressing up to receive endless streams of strangers, walking around in casual dishabille, or effectively becoming a prisoner in her own chamber. The personal breach between George Washington and his mother was never truly healed. In fact, the nation’s first president did not even attend her funeral. Abraham Lincoln, Legal Practice, and the Weight of Emancipation A similar pattern of saintly myth-making surrounds Abraham Lincoln, though his ultimate legacy as the Great Emancipator remains monumental. While practicing law in Illinois prior to his presidency, Lincoln represented a Kentucky slave owner named Robert Matson. Five of Matson’s slaves had traveled with him into Lincoln’s home state before deciding to run away. Because Illinois was a free soil state, the ensuing legal chaos landed squarely in court. During the proceedings, Lincoln argued on behalf of his client that owners of "property"—which enslaved people were legally considered at the time—should be permitted to take their human "cargo" anywhere in the country without interference from local state laws. Lincoln ultimately lost the case. The court ruled that slavery was a direct "contravention of the Illinois Constitution," and the Black family involved was officially declared free. This chapter of Lincoln’s legal career is rarely taught in standard classrooms or featured in mainstream discussions about the sixteenth president. Yet, the mythology surrounding Lincoln ultimately aligns with his tragic fate. President Lincoln ultimately lost his life because he remained deeply adamant about ending slavery in the United States once and for all. The assassin John Wilkes Booth, driven by intense racist animus, was motivated to kill Lincoln at Ford’s Theatre in Washington, D.C., precisely because the president staunchly supported freedom and civil rights for Black Americans. As detailed in O’Reilly’s book Killing Lincoln, the immense stress of trying to banish slavery and win the Civil War took a severe physical toll on the president, breaking down his entire body through a horrendous ordeal. Despite complicated early legal representation, O’Reilly views Lincoln as the finest president the nation has ever produced. The underlying lesson is that human beings can change and redemption is possible, but the unvarnished truth often gets buried beneath layers of hagiography. Theodore Roosevelt and the Ultimate Household Challenge Perhaps some of the most colorful folklore surrounds Theodore Roosevelt, a man who intensely disliked being called "Teddy" because the moniker reminded him of his sickly childhood. Those in his inner circle knew to address him as Theodore, Colonel, or Mr. President. Roosevelt was an extraordinary executive who nevertheless grappled with very common, highly relatable domestic problems. Following the tragic death of his first wife, Alice, during childbirth, he married Edith, a capable woman who nonetheless struggled to control six rambunctious children. Chief among them was her teenage stepdaughter, Alice Roosevelt—named after her late mother. Alice functioned essentially as a juvenile delinquent of her era. To the absolute horror of her traditional Protestant father, she openly declared herself a "pagan" and dismissed traditional Christianity as "sheer voodoo." Her social life provided a constant source of anxiety for the White House. Alice was fond of roaming the streets of Washington, D.C., with unmarried young men, partying late into the night. Local authorities frequently had to corral her and return her to the executive mansion. Unfazed by the escorts, Alice retaliated by sneaking young men into the people’s house. She also enjoyed smoking cigarettes; when her parents banned the habit indoors, she defied them by sneaking up to the roof of the White House to smoke in secret. President Theodore Roosevelt famously captured his exasperation with his rebellious daughter by noting, "I can either run the country or I can control Alice, but I cannot possibly do both!" The folklore surrounding Alice continued even after her father left office. In 1909, as the Roosevelt family moved out of the White House, she reportedly buried a voodoo doll of the incoming First Lady, Helen "Nelly" Taft, right in the front yard. Upon moving in, the Tafts discovered the disturbing figurine and permanently banished Alice from the premises. Unbeknownst to them, she may have also left behind a pet garter snake named Emily Spinach inside the building. The Danger of Political Mythology These historical accounts illustrate that accurate reporting and public perception regarding American presidents have always posed a challenge for political parties and the media. Today, that media apparatus operates at a level of distortion and partisanship unlike anything seen previously in American history. While covering up presidential shortcomings is fundamentally dishonest, the stakes in modern politics demand absolute clarity regarding the individuals entrusted with national power. As Confronting America argues, the pervasive habit of mythologizing historical and political figures ultimately harms everyone, clouding public judgment when clear-eyed reality is needed most. Post navigation The Night Before Issus: How New Discoveries Reveal the Human Reality Behind Alexander the Great