Long before the modern American civil rights movement gained widespread momentum in the mid-20th century, a remarkably courageous Southern white woman named Lillian Smith was already on the front lines, fighting fiercely to dismantle the entrenched systems of segregation that defined the American South. Writing best-selling books that challenged the racial status quo, Smith faced intense backlash, including having her works censored, banned, and even publicly burned across the country. Yet, despite her profound contributions to American literature and social justice, her name has largely faded from the public consciousness today.

In a reflective and revealing piece, historian Keri Leigh Merritt, author of An Inconvenient Woman, brings this vital historical figure back into the spotlight, arguing that Smith’s legacy deserves to be widely recognized and deeply honored.

Merritt recalls the first time she arrived on Old Screamer Mountain in Clayton, Georgia, which served as Smith’s home for the majority of her sixty-eight years. It was early fall, and the leaves had begun their slow descent into their final weeks of life, illuminating the clear sky with a vibrant array of colors—oranges, reds, golds, maroons, mustards, and burnt siennas—reminding all who beheld them how mournfully short life can be. While Merritt had visited Clayton many times before to hike the trails of the Appalachians, she had never visited Smith’s sanctuary. Upon arrival, it immediately felt serenely familiar, feeling very much like home.

As Merritt would discover in the months that followed, her own life and career shared striking parallels with that of Lillian Smith. Both women were born in other Deep South states—Smith in Florida and Merritt in Mississippi—and both eventually claimed Georgia as their home, despite fiercely and bitterly disagreeing with the vast majority of the state’s white citizens. Both experienced childhoods burdened by troubling, complex relationships with their mothers, and both were profoundly educated by extensive travel, particularly abroad, during their teenage and young adult years. Furthermore, both women had their life’s work interrupted by serious illness and had to overcome several major personal losses along the way.

The philosophical alignment between the two writers was equally striking. Both Smith and Merritt believed that the key to dismantling systemic racism involved a multifaceted combination of personal relationships, education, art, psychology, and policy. Both began their public speaking careers through civil rights organizations and college campuses throughout the South, as well as through various private organizations in New York. They shared a temperament defined by impatience and moral rigor—or righteousness, as Merritt cheerfully admits—alongside an admittedly sometimes too-intolerant stance toward intolerance itself. Ultimately, both women held progressive viewpoints that far outpaced those of most white Americans of their respective generations.

Intrigued by the tiny, wire-framed woman from Old Screamer Mountain, Merritt began researching Smith in earnest and was immediately enthralled. She discovered a white woman who had fought to end segregation as early as the 1930s, a best-selling author whose provocative books were censored, burned, and banned in multiple cities across America, and an openly queer woman who lived with her lifelong partner, Paula Snelling. It became clear to Merritt that Smith had been nearly erased from the historical record precisely because she posed—and in many ways still poses—a direct threat to prevailing social hierarchies and traditional power structures.

Remembering Lillian Smith

Despite this historical sidelining, Lillian Smith and her ideas undoubtedly deserve to be known by every American. Merritt contends that Smith’s essays should be required reading in classrooms nationwide, and that entire college courses should be devoted to her written work and political activism. As Merritt’s scholarly interest blossomed into a full-length book project, she began working closely with Matthew Teutsch, who served as the Director of the Lillian Smith Center before the institution was defunded by Piedmont University. For years, Teutsch worked tirelessly to restore Smith’s long-obscured legacy, culminating on April 20, 2022, when Lillian E. Smith finally received her own historical marker from the Georgia Historical Society.

The text of the marker reads in part: “Smith openly challenged Jim Crow and provided a critical White voice on Southern race relations through her writings, including the novel Strange Fruit and memoir Killers of the Dream, and a literary magazine co-edited with her life partner Paula Snelling. Through her involvement with Civil Rights organizations, Smith became friends with Martin Luther King, Jr.”

By explicitly recognizing Paula Snelling as Lillian’s life and intellectual partner, the marker achieved a groundbreaking milestone, becoming one of—if not the very—first historical markers in the Deep South to formally recognize a same-sex relationship. It also stands as one of the few markers in the entire state of Georgia honoring a woman. In a landscape awash with Civil War markers, the revolutionary nature of Lillian Smith’s plaque cannot be overstated. Among thousands of monuments dedicated primarily to men, and virtually none to LGBTQ+ individuals, Smith’s plaque remains a rare testament to a white Southerner honored specifically for her unwavering dedication to civil rights.

By the time the plaque was officially approved, Merritt had delivered several speeches on the importance of Lillian Smith and her work, cementing her reputation as a leading expert on the author. Consequently, Dr. Teutsch asked Merritt to deliver the keynote speech dedicating the historic marker. It was at that precise moment that Merritt realized she needed to put her other scholarly projects aside and finish writing An Inconvenient Woman, marking the first book to deal comprehensively with Smith’s life, work, and sexuality in four decades.

In her dedication speech, Merritt focused on how Lillian Smith exposed the deep-seated sins of white America while simultaneously holding onto an enduring hope that lit a path forward. Smith possessed a unique ability to scold and preach, yet she would consistently welcome back sinners with open arms and a forgiving heart. According to Smith, the fundamental key to achieving true peace lay in creating entirely new identities for white supremacists whose self-images had been deeply shattered by modernity and social progress.

“When a man gives up something, even old defenses, he is not going to feel good unless he has something equal, or better, returned to him,” Smith once wrote. “We must give our people new beliefs, new images of themselves to substitute for the old.”

These principles—forging new beliefs and new images of the self—offer a vital blueprint to help heal modern society even today. As Merritt emphasized during the dedication of the historical marker, it remains imperative to keep Lillian Smith’s name and her important mission alive, allowing her legacy to both guide and inspire contemporary generations. Let her extraordinary life serve as a constant reminder of the hard, often selfless, and occasionally dangerous work required to build a genuinely equitable, peaceful, and loving society, inspiring individuals to take up the mantle in honor and remembrance of Smith and all fearless freedom fighters.