In the life of a journalist, particularly one focused on the intricate and often intangible world of spirituality, the success of an interview is rarely measured by the transcript. Sometimes, the most profound insights are not found in the answers to carefully prepared questions, but in the moments where the planned narrative falls away, leaving behind a raw, human encounter. As the editor-in-chief of Tricycle, I have spent decades facilitating conversations with some of the most influential Buddhist thinkers of our time. Yet, as I look back on my career, it is not the perfectly polished Q&As that stand out most vividly. Rather, it is the “failed” interviews—the ones that defied my agenda and forced me to abandon the role of reporter for the role of student—that remain etched in my memory. My first encounter with the boundaries of journalistic control occurred during an attempt to interview the revered Burmese meditation master Sayadaw U Pandita. A towering figure in the Vipassana tradition, Sayadaw U Pandita was a man who lived the practice with uncompromising rigor. When I arrived, notebook in hand and a list of questions regarding the challenges of meditation, I was fully prepared for a scholarly exchange. I wanted to extract wisdom that I could translate into a neat, digestible article for our readers. Read Also: Beyond Certainty: Nagapriya on the Pragmatic Value of Buddhist Viewpoints Reframing the Self: How Karma and Not-Self Work Together in Buddhist Practice The master, however, had other plans. He was entirely uninterested in being a subject for a profile. Instead, he turned the tables, treating our meeting not as a professional engagement, but as a direct inquiry into my own spiritual life. "Where do you feel the breath?" he asked, piercing through my carefully constructed professional demeanor. When I tried to steer the conversation back to the mechanics of working through difficult meditation experiences, he interrupted again, asking, "When do you sit? Mornings or evenings?" The interrogation was relentless, though entirely gentle. It was a masterclass in redirection. He wasn’t avoiding my questions; he was highlighting the fact that my questions were theoretical, whereas his interest was experiential. Eventually, the futility of my position became clear. I was trying to observe the practice from the outside, while he was insisting I participate in it from the inside. I switched off my recording device, set aside my pen, and allowed myself to be a student. In that moment, the interview failed by every traditional metric, but it succeeded in ways that no article ever could. A similar, though distinctly different, experience occurred years later with the late Robert A. F. Thurman. Bob, who served as the Je Tsongkhapa Professor of Indo-Tibetan Buddhist Studies at Columbia University, was a force of nature. He was a man of outsize personality, defined by his booming voice, his lumbering, deliberate gait, and an energy that seemed to charge the air the moment he walked into a room. His physical presence was as memorable as his intellect; he famously wore a glass eye, a feature that did nothing to hide the intensity of his gaze but instead added a layer of waggish, disarming charm. Bob was a bridge between worlds. He was a scholar who refused to remain sequestered in the ivory tower, and he challenged the prevailing stereotypes that often painted Buddhist spirituality as a quiet, withdrawn, or purely monastic endeavor. He was unabashedly social, intellectually hungry, and deeply committed to the idea that Buddhist practice should be a vibrant, public-facing activity. He broadened our understanding of what a bodhisattva could look like in the modern world, proving that one could be deeply engaged in politics, culture, and social discourse while maintaining a profound connection to the dharma. The impact of his life and work was felt across the American dharma scene for decades. Since his passing at his home in Woodstock, New York, this past June, there has been a great deal of reflection on his legacy. As noted in the obituary by Tricycle contributing editor Joan Duncan Oliver, Bob’s contributions were foundational to the development of Buddhism in the West. This was something I observed firsthand during the 1990s. Whenever I interviewed prospective employees for the magazine, I would ask how they had first encountered the teachings. Time and again, the answer was the same: "I learned about Buddhism from Professor Thurman." Many of them affectionately referred to him as "Buddha Bob" or "Tenzin Bob," and it was clear that he had not only educated them but had acted as a conduit, pointing them toward our work and the broader community. In the early 2000s, I traveled to Bob’s home near Columbia University to interview him about his then-recent work, The Holy Teaching of Vimalakirti: A Mahayana Scripture. The book was a remarkable achievement, bringing the story of the enlightened layman Vimalakirti to life for a modern audience. I was particularly struck by Bob’s accessible prose and his meticulous glossaries, which bridged the gap between ancient terminology and contemporary relevance. I arrived with my questions about the sutra, hoping to explore the nuances of its message. But once again, the interview took a turn I hadn’t anticipated. Bob had no intention of sticking to the text. He wanted to talk about the world. We spent the better part of the afternoon discussing politics, the weight of our endless wars, and the intricacies of the Bush dynasty. Every time I attempted to bring him back to the sutra, he would skillfully weave the conversation back to the Tibetan teachings on compassion and the difficult, necessary practice of loving one’s enemies. Just as with Sayadaw U Pandita, I eventually realized that the interview was not going to follow my itinerary. But I was not for a moment bored. I was, in fact, taken on a conversational joy ride, guided by a man who saw the connections between ancient scripture and the messy reality of 21st-century life. We were only interrupted when his wife, Nena, stepped in to remind Bob of his next commitment. I left that day without the material I had come for, but I walked away with something much more valuable: a memory of a mind that was constantly in motion, refusing to be contained by a single topic or a single perspective. The irony, which I have come to appreciate deeply, is that the interview is all the more memorable precisely because it was a "failure." The contrast between these two experiences highlights the diversity of the Buddhist path. Sayadaw U Pandita’s approach was about inward focus, about returning to the breath and the simplicity of the present moment. He was a mirror, reflecting my own mind back at me. Bob, by contrast, was a magnificent voyager. His talks were expansive, taking me to unexpected places and showing me how the dharma could be applied to the largest questions of existence and society. A few years ago, I had the opportunity to host Bob on a Zoom call. It was a chance to reconnect and reflect on the time that had passed. More than anything he said during that call, I remember the broadness of his smile, the infectious, mischievous nature of his laugh, and the clear delight he took in the dharma. He still possessed that same energy, and he still carried himself with a sense of wonder. During our conversation, I brought up that failed interview from decades before. He chuckled and suggested that we would have to revisit The Holy Teaching of Vimalakirti sometime in the future. We never did get that chance. But in the end, perhaps the unfinished nature of those conversations is the most appropriate way to honor them. They were not puzzles to be solved or stories to be wrapped up; they were invitations to keep exploring, to keep questioning, and to remain open to the unexpected turns the path might take. Post navigation A Quiet Awakening: Exploring the Buddhist Landscape of Zagreb Bridging Traditions: Sunisa Manning and the Evolution of the Heart Sangha