In his latest contribution to the winter 2026 issue of Tricycle, author and teacher Ken McLeod presents a profound thought experiment that challenges our understanding of reality, self-consciousness, and the nature of compassion. By inviting readers to step into a lucid dream, McLeod opens a doorway into the core tenets of Mahayana Buddhism, suggesting that our most authentic, unconditioned responses arise precisely when we stop thinking and allow the inherent clarity of our nature to take the lead.

The Dreamer’s Dilemma: A Lesson in Spontaneous Kindness

The scenario posed by McLeod is simple yet haunting. Imagine you are in a picturesque park during early summer, fully aware that you are dreaming. You perceive the warmth of the sun, the shade of ancient oaks, and the serene movement of ducks and swans on a pond. In this state, you are entirely conscious that the park, the town, and your own sense of self are merely movements of your own mind.

Into this scene walks a woman, visibly distraught. She moves with heavy, labored steps, her body bent with grief, her face streaked with tears. She collapses beside you, confessing, “They killed my daughter.” The dilemma is immediate: knowing that the woman, the park, and the tragedy are all illusions within a dream, how do you respond?

When McLeod poses this question to students and practitioners, the answer is almost universally consistent: “I comfort her.” When pressed on the fact that the interaction is entirely illusory—that the woman is not “real”—the response remains firm. People reply, “That’s just what you do.”

McLeod uses this as a springboard to illustrate a fundamental Buddhist concept. When he asks what was happening in the minds of those who offered comfort, the common response is, “Nothing. My mind was clear.” This, he argues, is the essence of the “clear, empty mind” that many traditions refer to as buddha-nature, the union of emptiness and compassion, or the unconditioned. It is a nonconceptual knowing that exists beneath the surface of our frantic, analytical thought processes. It is the aim of Mahayana practice: to reach that space where thinking drops away, allowing a compassionate response to arise without hesitation or calculation.

The Two Facts: Navigating the Mystery of Experience

To understand this, McLeod suggests we look at life through the lens of two fundamental, inseparable facts: the fact of life and the fact of mystery. The “fact of life” is our experience of being an individual navigating a world filled with people, places, and events. The “fact of mystery” is the inexplicable nature of that experience. We have no idea what awareness is, where it begins, or where it ends. We cannot point to a core essence that makes us “us,” yet we are undeniably aware.

“That’s Just What You Do”

In Buddhist philosophy, these are often categorized as the relative and absolute truths. However, McLeod warns against treating these as purely academic or conceptual distinctions. They are, he argues, more like the heat and light of a flame—distinct, yet inseparable. He employs the analogy of water and waves to illustrate this relationship. The “mystery” is the water, the fundamental substance of reality, while the “fact of life” is represented by the waves. A wave cannot exist without the water, yet we often mistake the individual wave for something independent, existing in its own right.

When we lose sight of the fact that we are all “waves” of the same substance, we begin to struggle, drowning in the confusion of believing that the “perceiving self” and the “world out there” are separate entities. The goal of Mahayana practice is to awaken to both facts simultaneously: to exist in the mystery without being confused by the labels of self, and to participate in the life of the world without being overwhelmed by the volatility of its waves.

Awakening Through Practice: From Sutras to Mind Training

How does one bridge the gap between conceptual, analytical thinking and this direct, nonconceptual knowing? McLeod points to a variety of methods, but he places particular emphasis on the power of reading sutras aloud—a practice he notes is traditional in the East but often overlooked in the West.

Recalling his own experience reading the Diamond Sutra, McLeod describes how the paradox of liberating countless beings while knowing no being is actually liberated caused his mind to stop. There was no internal monologue, no analysis—only a profound, empty clarity. This experience, which he describes as a shift in his very foundation, led him to translate the text into accessible English as This Unexpected Jewel. He suggests that the act of reading such texts aloud can disrupt our rigid patterns of thought, allowing the “fact of mystery” to reveal itself.

For awakening to the “fact of life,” McLeod advocates for the Tibetan Buddhist tradition of mind training, or lojong. This practice centers on the four immeasurables—equanimity, loving-kindness, compassion, and joy—and applies them directly to the chaotic reality of our daily existence.

The core of this practice is the exchange of self for other, or “taking and sending.” With every breath, the practitioner visualizes taking in the suffering, greed, and cruelty of the world, transforming it, and sending out joy, health, and freedom. Initially, the practitioner may approach this with the hope of self-improvement or personal relief, but over time, this self-centered motivation evaporates. The practitioner begins to see that the cruelty and pain they witness in others are not external problems, but reflections of a shared struggle.

“That’s Just What You Do”

This realization is transformative. When one understands the agony of being the person who causes harm, the response is no longer judgment, but an overwhelming, unconditional compassion. We begin to see that everyone—regardless of their actions—is struggling with the same existential weight. As we give away our own cherished talents, peace, and security, we lose our narrow grip on preference and prejudice.

The End of Confusion

As this practice deepens, the practitioner’s ability to remain steady in the face of life’s turbulence increases. The reactions that once caused us to spiral—anger, desire, fear—begin to be experienced simply as waves rising and falling upon the water of our awareness. We recognize that while our experiences are real, they lack the inherent, solid existence we once attributed to them.

This realization is not a path to apathy, but to greater agency. By understanding that everything is a movement of the mind, we are freed from the reactive confusion that usually dictates our behavior. Just as the person in the dream knew instinctively to comfort the grieving woman because “that’s just what you do,” the awakened practitioner develops a similar, spontaneous capacity for kindness.

In this state, the mystery of awareness and the magic of life are experienced with greater clarity. We no longer need to calculate our kindness or deliberate on our morality. We simply live as well as we can, helping those we encounter because it is the most natural, human response to the shared, mysterious reality we all inhabit. In the end, this is the fruition of Mahayana practice: a life where compassion is not a duty, but a natural expression of being.